Real Estate Weekly
Image default

Courts come to sensible conclusion in major NYC rent case

The health of the real estate industry in New York City depends on consistent, reliable and sound rule of law and regulations.

That is why the Real Estate Board of New York applauds the recent New York State Court of Appeals case regarding the high rent, vacancy deregulation provisions of the rent stabilization law.

A ruling in favor of the plaintiff would have upended the status quo and negatively impacted the owners of thousands of deregulated apartments across the city – even though those owners obeyed the law and followed the rules.

The ruling finally settles a dispute over the deregulation of a previously rent-stabilized unit in the West Village that began in 2005. The owner of the apartment deregulated the apartment at that time in full accordance with the law. That is where the dispute began.

When the tenant vacated that unit, the rent was $1,829.49. After the application of a 20 percent vacancy allowance which is permitted under the law, the legal rent exceed the then-$2,000 threshold for deregulation and was deregulated.

Vacancy allowance increases have been included in the calculation of the legal rents of regulated apartments since the Rent Regulation Reform Act of 1997. An estimated 100,000 apartments across the five boroughs were deregulated by the high rent vacancy deregulation provisions.

Previous legal decisions in this case, including an appellate court decision in 2015 and a prior ruling from the New York State Supreme Court, had found that the law required that the vacancy deregulation threshold had to be attained prior to vacancy and the inclusion of the vacancy allowance. In these decisions, the courts concluded that the landlord acted illegally and owed the tenant money from overcharged rent.

These decisions, if reaffirmed by the Court of Appeals, would have put in jeopardy the many thousands of apartments owners across the city that were deregulated when the legal rent after vacancy and allowable rent increases such as a vacancy allowance was calculated. The financial impact on residential building owners would be enormous and would have created chaos in the residential rental market.
But the New York State Court of Appeals, the state’s highest court, finally settled the dispute and ruled that the owner had the right under the law to apply a vacancy allowance to the vacated tenant’s rent and that the subsequent total brought the legal rent above the deregulation threshold and that the apartment was legally deregulated.

Accordingly, the tenant was not entitled to the alleged rent overcharges and damages that the earlier decisions had imposed.

This important decision reaffirms the long-standing legal practice and commonly-held understanding of the Rent Stabilization Law’s vacancy decontrol provisions.

This decision is a win for stability. Owners of deregulated rent-stabilized apartments over the period between 1997 and 2011 can now rest assured that the rules governing deregulation have been clearly affirmed by the Court of Appeals.

All in all, overturning the lower court decision returns the state of the city’s residential rental market to the original, agreed-upon status quo. The lower court decision had previously introduced uncertainty in this market and caused widespread concern among residential rental building owners who had deregulated units in accordance with their understanding of the law which was reinforced by the State’s housing agency.

The Real Estate Board of New York welcomes this important affirmation of the high rent, vacancy deregulation rules – and so should all New Yorkers concerned with consistent and fair interpretation of the law.

In Other REBNY News

How do you choose the right people? How do you leverage your team properly to increase your business? When is the right time to start your own team? Learn how to enhance your skills in building a team at our next free-for-members Breakfast Club Seminar: How to Run a Team with Eric Barron and Tyler Whitman of Triplemint, along with Ari Harkov of Halstead Property, and Eugene Litvak of Compass. Register online to attend the event, sponsored by Citibank, on Tuesday, May 8th from 9:30 to 11:00 a.m. at REBNY’s Mendik Education Center.

Learn from Top Brokers and Industry Leaders – “Road Map to Success: Identifying Your Route” on Tuesday, May 22nd at 5:30 p.m. at the Mendik Education Center. Ken Scheff of Stribling & Associates will moderate this discussion featuring Mirza Avdovic and Kellee Buhler of Compass Real Estate, Joanna Mayfield Marks of Halstead Property, and Jennifer Morcheles of REAL NY Properties. Register now via email:

On Thursday, May 31st from 7:30 to 10:00 a.m. at our 15th Annual Commercial Management Leadership Breakfast, we will honor outstanding leaders in the field of commercial property management at the New York Hilton Midtown (1335 Avenue of the Americas). The awards to be presented are the: Edward A. Riguardi Commercial Management Executive of the Year Award, John M. Griffin Community Service Award, the On-Site Manager of the Year Award, the Portfolio Manager of the Year Award, the Small Building Engineer of the Year Award, the Large Building Engineer of the Year Award, the Security Professional of the Year Award, the Porter of the Year Award, the Rising Star of the Year Award, and the Best Engine Room Award. Register now to attend and email for sponsorship opportunities.

Stay in front of New York City’s top retail dealmakers by sponsoring our 20th Annual Retail Deal of the Year Cocktail Party on Tuesday, June 12th, from 5:30 to 7:30 p.m. at Club 101 (101 Park Avenue). For more information on sponsorship opportunities, email

Enjoy a summer day of golf and tennis while networking with NYC real estate professionals at our Annual Golf and Tennis Outing on Monday, July 30th at the North Shore Country Club. Take advantage of this opportunity to advertise your company, sponsor the event, and provide promotional items or raffle donations. Your company will be credited on the invitation sent to REBNY membership, and in the event program. Register online and email for sponsorship opportunities.

Related posts

Never count New York out

James Whelan

Broker confidence hits record lows amid coronavirus crisis


Even amid coronavirus crisis, the census is vitally important

James Whelan